Oh my word! This chicken and potato pie is heaven on a plate. It’s one of our favourite winter comfort food dishes. The chicken is oh so tender and the sauce is deliciously creamy. It’s also packed full of vegetables and fussy kid approved! I make a big batch for the freezer so we can enjoy this Chicken and Potato Pie for months.

Ingredients To Make Chicken and Potato Pie
- 1.8kg Chicken Drum Fillets £7.98
- 1kg Onions 95p
- 1 Bulb Garlic 22p
- 1 kg Leeks £2.74
- 4 Cubes Chicken Stock 23p
- 100ml Lemon Juice 28p
- 300ml Crème Fresh 75p
- 100g Dijon Mustard 25p
- 100g Plain Flour 5p
- 500ml Milk 35p
- 2.5kg Potatoes £1.49
- 150g Butter 26p
- 250g Cheese £1.35
Total Cost = £16.90
Makes 32 servings = 53p per serving

This Chicken and Potato Pie recipe uses full packs of most of the ingredients. This means that there is absolutely zero food waste. No leftovers in the fridge to throw out later. No guilt. And no wasted money.
Chicken drum fillets are the cheapest boneless chicken that’s typically availible from the supermarkets. When you’re going to be dicing the chicken like in this Chicken and Potato Pie recipe you might as well save the money and opt for the cheaper cut of meat.
Look out for wonky or budget vegetables. They might be a bit misshapen or uneven but they are just as fresh and tasty as their premium counterparts. You won’t be able to tell the difference once they are cooked but you will notice the difference in your bank balance.
As with most recipes you can substitute butter for margarine. Real butter would taste better if your budget can accommodate it. I tend to opt for the fake butter which is a mix of butter and margarine.
Food purchased from Aldi. Prices correct at time of publishing.
Cooking Equipment You Will Need to Make Chicken and Potato Pie
You do not need a lot of equipment to batch cook. You can get started with tools you probably already have in your kitchen.
To make Chicken and Potato Pie you will need:
- Kitchen Knife
- Chopping Board
- 2 Large Pans
- Freezer and Oven Proof Dishes
There are some tools that will make batch cooking quicker and easier.
A potato peeler will make peeling your potatoes much quicker and easier than using a knife.
I like to use a garlic press but you can mince your garlic with a knife if you prefer.
A cheese grater is the quickest and easiest way to grate your cheese but for this Chicken and Potato Pie recipe you could chop it into small chunks by hand if you don’t own a cheese grater.
A measuring jug is very useful for measuring the milk and weighing scales for measuring the dry ingredients. However, none of the quantities in this recipe are crucial so you could “eye ball” any of them and it will be fine.
I do like to use my stand mixer to get delightfully fluffy mashed potato but it really isn’t necessary. You can get perfectly good mashed potato with a potato masher or even just a fork, it just takes more work.
Chicken and Potato Pie Recipe
Start by mincing the garlic.

There are a few different ways to mince garlic. Give them a try and find your favourite.

Dice the onions.

Finely slice the leeks.
Add the leeks, garlic and onion to a large pan and fry them in butter.

Cut the chicken into bite sized pieces and add them to the pan.

Pour over enough flour to coat all of the chicken and stir it in.

Add the chicken stock. I’m using home made chicken stock because I have some to hand. Usually I make this recipe with four chicken stock cubes.

Add the crème fresh.

Then add half a small jar of Dijon mustard. Don’t worry, it’s not spicy, the crème fresh makes the mustard deliciously creamy with none of the heat but all of the flavour.

Next add about half a bottle of lemon juice.

Pour over enough milk to cover the chicken mixture. I used about 500ml of milk.

Sometimes I add a pack of frozen peas. I think it makes the pie taste better and adds an extra portion of veggies but my Little Miss has requested that I make this Chicken and Potato Pie without the peas.
Leave the pan to simmer while you cook the potatoes. Stir it every now and then so that it doesn’t burn to the bottom of the pan.
Peel and chop your potatoes. Put them in a large pan with plenty of water and bring to the boil.

Once the chicken is just barely cooked, just at that point at which you’d normally cook it a bit longer “just to be on the safe side”. Portion the chicken mixture into freezer and oven proof dishes. Fill each dish about 3/4 full of chicken.

Once the potatoes are well cooked and soft drain off the water. Then add a good amount of butter and about 250g of grated cheese. Give them a really good mashing until they’re nice and smooth.

Spoon the mashed potatoes over the chicken. Run your fork over the top of the mashed potatoes to make little ridges. These will crisp up beautifully in the oven and are deliciously tasty.

How to Cook Chicken and Potato Pie
Pop your chicken and potato pie in the oven at about Gas Mark 4 / 180°C / 350°F for about 40 minutes. Check it’s piping hot and the mash should have crisped up nicely.

How to Store Chicken and Potato Pie
Store it in an airtight container in the fridge for up to 3 days.
How to Freeze Chicken and Potato Pie
Cover your oven dishes with either cling film or a plastic lid and leave them to cool.
I recently invested in a set of these glass oven dishes with reusable plastic lids.
I save on using cling film but they are also stackable even before they’re frozen which I find much more convenient. If I’m using cling film I have to find spaces in my freezer with nothing stacked on top until the dishes are fully frozen. With these plastic lids I can easily stack my dishes while they freeze.
Once your Chicken and Potato Pie has cooled down put the tubs into your fridge. Once they are chilled pop them in your freezer to freeze.
How to Defrost Chicken and Potato Pie
For best results (as they say) take your tub of Chicken and Potato Pie out of the freezer a day or two before you plan to eat it.
I like to plan my meals a few days in advance and choose from the defrosted meals on the day. That way there’s still some room for spontaneity.
How to Serve Chicken and Potato Pie
We like our chicken and potato pies served with broccoli and sweetcorn – because these are the only vegetables that Little Miss will voluntarily eat. We have it with baked beans sometimes but I find the flavour of the tomato sauce distracts from the delicious creaminess of the chicken sauce.
I do hope this chicken and potato pie recipe inspires you to have a go at batch cooking.
Follow me on your favourite social media channel for a new recipe every week.

More Batch Cook Recipes
Cut the Cost of Crafting
Get budget-friendly craft projects and batch cook recipes in your inbox.
Pin It Now, Cook It Later
Pin this Chicken and Potato Pie Recipe to your Pinterest for later.

A Note on Food Safety
Freezing and defrosting food really isn’t complicated. But it terrifies me how many people aren’t familiar with basic food hygiene so if you’re new to cooking from scratch and freezing please follow these safety guidlines.
The important things to remember are:
- Wash your hands and anything else that has been in contact with raw meat.
- Meals should last for about 3 days in the fridge.
- Do not defrost your meals at room temperature.
- Do not refreeze meals you have already defrosted.
- Consume food before the use by date.

A Little Bit About Me . . .
Hey there I’m Bridie, a busy mum to two amazing humans, a spirited border collie puppy and a pair of sweet guinea pigs. We homestead in a cherished Edwardian terrace in not so sunny Lancashire, England.
When I’m not spending time with my children and menagerie, I’m usually to be found in my craft room creating and blogging or in the kitchen cooking up a big batch of something tasty. I’m always looking for thrifty hacks to save money on my crafts and recipes. Crafting doesn’t have to cost a fortune!
I have been batch cooking for about 30 years (yikes that makes me feel old!) I’m sharing all my batch cook recipes, in depth batch cooking tutorials and all my tips and tricks to help you slash your food bills.
Each week I cook up a big batch of a single meal. Most of it goes in the freezer, then it’s just defrost and reheat or sling it in the oven. Even on busy school nights my family get to enjoy healthy home cooked meals that my kids actually eat.
Each week I share a new recipe on my blog. Most of my meals cost less than £1 per portion.
I really hope that my ideas can help you to stretch your budget.

I’ve included links to my favourite retailers for the products I’ve used to make my crafts. Click on any of the product images and links for full details. If you decide to buy any of these products I may get a small percentage of what you spend. There’s no cost to you at all.
Aran Knitting Baby Baby Scrapbooking Batch Cooking Beginner Scrapbooking Beginner Sewing Pattern Birthday Cards Budget Recipes Cards for Children Chicken Recipes Christmas Christmas Cards Craft Sensations Dovecraft Easy Recipe Easy Sewing Pattern Elasticated Channel First Edition Free Knitting Pattern Free Sewing Pattern Healthy Eating Healthy Recipe Knitting Accessories My Minds Eye Papermania Peek-a-Boo Patterns Polkadoodles ProMarkers Scrapbooking Sewing Sewing for Kids Sewing Pants Sewing Tops Sewing with Jersey Sewing with Wovens Simply Creative Sizzix Slow Cooker Recipes Soup Recipes Spellbinders Stitch Upon a Time Tim Holtz Top Stitching Winsor Newton XCut


















Leave a Reply