Shadows of the Workhouse Book Review

Having thoroughly enjoyed the first book, Call the Midwife I didn’t hesitate to buy the second book in the series. Second books do have a tendency to fall short of the quality of the first but I’m glad to say that this was not the case here. If anything it was even more thought provoking than the first book.


Shadows of the Workhouse: The Drama of Life in Postwar London
Shadows of the Workhouse: The Drama of Life in Post-war London

Sister Monica Joan

According to the author Sister Monica Joan (an elderly nun) mentions that her mothers ailing health was considered due to her tight corsets. Jennifer Worth calls them an instrument of torture.

Is this yet another example of the arrogance of medical practitioners?

Whilst corset wearing was very common among the upper classes, tight lacing as it is known was certainly not the norm. It is this practice of tight lacing that may have cause issues.

This being the case why would the doctors of the day identify this as the cause of her poor health? The woman in question was a mother of 35, not likely to be tight lacing.

I’m guessing that the male doctors of the day had very little knowledge of female undergarments. They simply assumed that they would be restrictive and backed up their conclusion with the rare cases of damage caused by tight lacing.

Therefore instead of actually trying to ascertain the cause of this lady’s poor health they simply put it down to her own behaviour, thereby shifting the blame squarely onto her shoulders.

This sort of thing still happens today and unfortunately it’s not at all uncommon.

For example in childbirth there is a very common diagnosis known as “failure to progress”. The very name clearly implies that the mother has failed to progress labour effectively. The blame is placed squarely on the mother. No responsibility is borne by the medical professionals who have interrupted and interferred with the natural progression of labour.

Polycystic ovaries is a very common condition in modern women. One of the symptoms is a tendency to gain weight. For those with the condition losing weight involves near starvation dieting. Any sensible medical practitioner would advise against such extreme diets. And yet ladies who suffer from this condition are typically instructed to loose weight in order to manage the symptoms. Yet again the blame is placed on the patient and the medical practitioner is absolved of any responsibility to actually treat the condition.

Shadows Of The Workhouse: The Drama Of Life In Postwar London (Call The Midwife Book 2) Kindle Edition
Shadows Of The Workhouse: The Drama Of Life In Post-war London (Call The Midwife Book 2)

It seems that we haven’t made much progress in the last 100 years. You’d think with more female doctors more progress would have been made. Unfortunately these ladies are still taught from textbooks written by their male predecessors. The arrogance and condescending attitude which seems to be typical of the profession seems to rub off on them.

Please let me be clear that there are some amazing doctors who actually listen to their patients without preformed judgements. Unfortunately in my experience as a woman, this is the exception and not the rule.

Women suffered through man’s ignorance

sister monica Joan, Shaows of the Workshouse

Jeseph Collett

The story of Jeseph Collett really touched me. It isn’t so much his experiences as much as his unfailing optimism. His gratitude for every tiny thing he had left.

Such a positive attitude seems like a very rare thing in modern times.

One of his stories in particular, brought me to tears. I’m not normally given to such emotional responses so this was unusual for me. In the book Joe remembers digging a little boy out of a bombed house. He was trapped under his mothers dead body. She had thrown herself on top of him, giving her life to protect her son.

Shadows Of The Workhouse: The Drama Of Life In Postwar London Hardcover
Shadows Of The Workhouse: The Drama Of Life In Post-war London Hardcover

As a mother I can understand her reaction. I wont say choice because I’m certain that her actions were completely based on instinct and her conscious mind had little involvement. I’m also certain that had her conscious mind had any influence over her actions, she would have done the same regardless.

As a modern mother I have apsolutley no experience of such actions being nesseccary.

I feel very guilty for not being more grateful for that fact.

My children have never known real hunger. They go without sweets all the time and if they don’t eat their dinner there’s nothing else. But they have never, not once, gone without being offered a square meal.

They work hard in school and walk nearly a mile to get there followed by homework and helping round the house. But my children will never know a days real hard labour, nor have I for that matter.

Shadows Of The Workhouse: The Drama Of Life In Postwar London (Call The Midwife) Paperback
Shadows Of The Workhouse: The Drama Of Life In Post-war London (Call The Midwife) Paperback

Conclusion

I love reading stories like this. They make me so grateful for everything I have. If these people can remain so positive in the face of such adversity then I certainly can be thankful for my privileged life.

I do find myself wondering how accurate the stories are. They are beautifully well written and deeply touching. However, many of these stories detail events when the author wasn’t present. They also contain details that I feel would be unlikely to be disclosed by those who were present.

Clearly the author has employed some artistic licence in order to make the stories flow nicely and I can’t blame her at all. I do hope she has stuck broadly to the facts and I certainly imagine that she has.

I am looking forward to reading the third instalment of Jennifer Worth’s memoirs.


Linking Up To: Creatively Crafty Link Party – Create, Bake, Grow & Gather Party – Farmhouse Friday – Inspire Me Monday – Dare to Share – Saturday Sparks Link Party – Friday With Friends – Home Matters Linky Party – Funtastic Friday Link Party – Link Up On the Edge


Peek-A-Boo Patterns Sewing Pattern on Sale
Polkadoodles Printables and Digital Stamps

A Little Bit About Me . . .

Hey there I’m Bridie, a busy mum to two amazing humans, a spirited border collie puppy and a pair of sweet guinea pigs. We homestead in a cherished Edwardian terrace in not so sunny Lancashire, England.

When I’m not spending time with my children and menagerie, I’m usually to be found in my craft room creating and blogging or in the kitchen cooking up a big batch of something tasty. I’m always looking for thrifty hacks to save money on my crafts and recipes. Crafting doesn’t have to cost a fortune!

Bridie @ Heart Hearth and Crafting

I’ve included links to my favourite retailers for the products I’ve used to make my crafts. Click on any of the product images and links for full details. If you decide to buy any of these products I may get a small percentage of what you spend. There’s no cost to you at all.


,

Aran Knitting Baby Baby Scrapbooking Batch Cooking Beginner Scrapbooking Beginner Sewing Pattern Birthday Cards Budget Recipes Cards for Children Chicken Recipes Christmas Christmas Cards Craft Sensations Dovecraft Easy Recipe Easy Sewing Pattern Elasticated Channel First Edition Free Knitting Pattern Free Sewing Pattern Healthy Eating Healthy Recipe Knitting Accessories My Minds Eye Papermania Peek-a-Boo Patterns Polkadoodles ProMarkers Scrapbooking Sewing Sewing for Kids Sewing Pants Sewing Tops Sewing with Jersey Sewing with Wovens Simply Creative Sizzix Slow Cooker Recipes Soup Recipes Spellbinders Stitch Upon a Time Tim Holtz Top Stitching Winsor Newton XCut

Hobbycraft

4 responses to “Shadows of the Workhouse Book Review”

  1. mhhwarmcozy Avatar
    mhhwarmcozy

    Birdie, I love the series call the midwife and am looking forward to reading the book! You were the most clicked at the FWF party. Thank you for sharing your book review with all of us!
    Rachelle

    1. Bridie Avatar

      Oh wow thank you so much!!

  2. Donna @ Modern on Monticello Avatar

    Thank you for sharing the book review. I have not heard of this series but you have definitely made me interested. Thanks for linking up this week. #HomeMattersParty

    1. Bridie Avatar

      It’s definitley worth reading. I guess it’s more popular in the UK as its set here.

Leave a Reply

I’m Bridie

Welcome to Heart and Hearth Crafts, my cosy corner of the internet dedicated to cutting the cost of crafting. Here you will find lots of projects and tutorials with tips and tricks to show you how to make creative projects you can be proud of on a budget. I’ll also show you how to save money in the kitchen too with weekly budget batch cook recipes.

Let’s connect

Polkadoodles Printables and Digital Stamps
Peek-A-Boo Patterns Sewing Pattern on Sale
Hobbycraft
Scrapbook.com
Peek-A-Boo Patterns